UNIVERSITY OF VERMONT

 2014 SUSTAINABLE PERENNIALS RESEARCH

Dr. Leonard P. Perry
Extension Professor

Sites:
H=Horticulture Research Center, So. Burlington, USDA zone 4b
Spring 2007 bulbs | Perennial trials listing (as of 2006)
photos: summer 1997 | 5/12/00 | 5/19/00 | 5/28/00 | 6/3/00 | 6/20/00
U=UVM greenhouses [view, 47K], Burlington, including outdoor student garden test beds, USDA zone 5b
M= Perry's Perennials, Milton, USDA zone 4a
Winter soil temperatures, Summer Soil Moisture, Climate data, Sunflower trials 2000 | 2002
W=Waterfront Park All-America selections flower display garden, Burlington, USDA zone 5b

Current | Past Studies

Slide show (ppt): Coralbells, Coneflowers, and Cold Climate Perennial Trials

 

Controlled Freezing, Hardiness of perennials:

In Fall 2012-Winter 2013, controlled freezing studies to the usual 5 subfreezing temperatures of 28, 23, 18, 12, 7F (-2, -5, -8, -11, -14C) in freezing chambers, for a minimum half hour to 2 hours maximum at each, was conducted in early January and late February on 7 perennial species, including 2 coneflowers ('Lucky Star' and 'PowWow Wild Berry').   Deacclimation studies were conducted on Coreopsis 'Route 66' and Leucanthemum 'Becky' on exposure to 60F for 1,3 or 5 days prior to exposure to the 5 subfreezing temperatures.  Similar studies are planned for winter 2014-15. (no studies were done in 2013-14) (Results 2013)

 

2012-15: National Ornamental Grass Trials

The zone 4 Milton (VT) site is one of 17 selected across the U.S. to trial new ornamental grasses, under the direction of Dr. Mary Meyer of the University of Minnesota.  These were planted in summer 2012 and are being evaluated the following 3 years.  Initially, with 4 replicates randomized of each cultivar, will be 5 selections of bluestem (Schizachyrium) and 17 of switchgrass (Panicum). (results and updates on wordpress blog at grasstrials.com). 

 

2014: New cultivar performance and hardiness trials

Over 200 new cultivars are being evaluated in trials in USDA zone 4b for performance, flower time and color, hardiness, pest problems, and potential for future studies or use in the region. Other trial sites include another in zone 4 (Full Circle Gardens, Essex Jct), zone 4b (Milton and the Justin Morrill Homestead in Strafford), and zone 5b (Burlington Waterfront Park). We continue as an official test site for introductions from Plant Haven. Blooms of Bressingham,  Ball Horticulture, as well as various other firms varying by year.

 

2008-present.  Coralbells field hardiness

In 2008, field trials were begun on coralbells (Heuchera) field hardiness,(updated 6/13) and continue with replacements and new additions with 90 cultivars as of fall 2012.  

 

2011-present.  Coneflower field hardiness

In 2011, field trials were begun on coneflower (Echinacea) field hardiness (updated 7/13), and continue with replacements and new additions with over 100 cultivars as of fall 2013.  

 

2014: Annuals are also being trialed at the Waterfront Park  in an official All America Selections Flower Display Garden which also include specialty annuals courtesy of DS Cole Growers and Pleasant View Gardens in New Hampshire.  

 

2012-14: Evaluating Flowering Plant Selection for Pollinator Habitat Enhancement: Open-Pollinated Natives vs. Native Cultivars (pollinatorgardens.org)

From 2012-2014 a study will be performed at three sites including a perennial and vegetable/berry grower, to determine effect on pollinators of native species compared to cultivars (nativars) of these species.  This project will be conducted by graduate assistant Annie White, and is funded largely by the SARE farmer/partnership program, with support too from Greenworks, Vermont. (overview of methods) (2013 SARE Research Report) NEW 2/14

Past Studies

Shrub rose evaluation (H,M):
Over 5 dozen cultivars of shrub roses (list and characters), emphasizing new series such as the Parkland, Meidiland, Explorer and David Austin ones, were evaluated among these sites and in cooperation with the University of Maine (Dr. Lois Stack) for hardiness, performance and disease resistance (rose ratings (updated 9.05)  article on top 15 rated to date).
photos: June 2003, north side | June 2003, inside

New cultivar performance and hardiness trials (H,M):
Emphasis in the past of the hundreds trialled was on perennial geraniums (spring observations)  (2001-2002 observations)  (photo 7/01),  monarda including new Dutch cultivars, Tiarella, Heuchera, Pulmonaria, and potentially hardy epimediums.

Hardiness of Low Groundcover Plants:
In 2007-2009 hardiness studies (funded by the New England Greenhouse Conference and New England Grows) involved the hardiness in 4-inch pots of 33 Steppables (courtesy Quansett Nurseries) and Nooks and Crannies (courtesy DS Cole Greenhouses). (final results of field and controlled freezing studies)

Controlled Freezing, Hardiness of perennials (U):
Deacclimation:  In 2008-09 a study began to examine various temperature regimes of deacclimation during midwinter (January) for Sedum 'Neon' and Salvia 'Rhapsody in Blue'.  Treatments included holding at 34F, one week or two weeks at 55F, one week of cycling between 34F and 55F, and one week at 40F.   In 2009-2010 the same deacclimation study was done with two additional perennials Achillea 'Apricot Delight' and Leucanthemum 'Becky'. Due to plants potted late in fall with insufficient time to establish, they overwintered poorly so results were not reliable.  In 2010-11 a similar study was done with 'Becky' and Tiarella 'Delaware', with exposure to various numbers of days (1,3,5,7) at 65F during the day, then back to 40F at night, prior to freezing to examine the effect of deacclimation on hardiness.  Few 'Becky' survived below 18F, which most 'Delaware' survived to the lowest temperatures of 8F, regardless of pretreatment. 

Several dozen perennials over several years are being frozen in controlled chest freezers to determine root killing temperatures; effects of cold intensity, duration, cycling, and rate of drop. These included heathers (Calluna) during 2001 and 2002.. Other freezing studies examined various factors affecting hardiness such as temperature cycling and rates of drop, and the effect on hardiness of dianthus, foamflower and perennial geranium. In part, these were from the M.S. thesis research of Cheryl Bruce (see abstract and slide show),  Andrea Luchini (2003 results , summary, thesis abstract, and slide show), and Sarah Kingsley Richards (Dec. 2011 article in Journal of Environmental Horticulture | thesis abstract | presentation). Results of these, and studies of previous grad students, are summarized in leaflet COH31.

In 2009-2010 studies were begun on the hardiness of Heuchera (coralbells) cultivars, particularly villosa hybrids (funding courtesy of New Hampshire Plant Endowment).  Plants were frozen to the five usual freezer temperatures (-2,-5,-8,-11,-14C) on two dates in January and March. Cultivars under study included: (links to result photos) 'Caramel', 'Mocha', 'Blackout', 'Frosted Violet', and 'Tiramisu.
(2009-2010 results).  In 2010-11 (results) five additional cultivars were frozen similarly, with few differences among temperatures from an early January freezing, but with significant differences from a late February freezing (plant survival decreasing significantly at 18F and below).  

2012: In Fall 2011-Winter 2012, Delaware Tiarella, Kahori Dianthus, and Bronze Wave Heuchera were acclimated for various times (none, 1, 2 or 4 weeks) at 40F after a period of temperatures 50F and above, then frozen to various temperatures to determine hardiness.  Tiarella and Heuchera also were subjected to two or no cycles below freezing (-7 to -9C and 0 to -2C) prior to controlled freezing.  Studies will be done on controlled freezing of 3 coneflower cultivars (White Swan, Pica Bella, Pixie Meadowbrite) both in January and late February, similar to recent studies with coralbells.  Controlled freezing also will be done on 4 other perennial cultivars in January (Raspberry Wine monarda, Raspbery Regal coralbells, Sherwood Purple phlox, Global Warming chrysanthemum).  

Shrub rose evaluation (H,M):
Over 5 dozen cultivars of shrub roses (list and characters), emphasizing new series such as the Parkland, Meidiland, Explorer and David Austin ones, were evaluated among these sites and in cooperation with the University of Maine (Dr. Lois Stack) for hardiness, performance and disease resistance (rose ratings (updated 9.05)  article on top 15 rated to date).
photos: June 2003, north side | June 2003, inside

Effect of soil moisture on hardiness
monitoring field soil moisture, and the effect on freezing of wet or dry watering regimes (below 10% and above 20% soil moisture content) on 3 cultivars (funding by the NH Horticulture Endowment); first year summary, first year photo Astilbe dry, Astilbe wet (second year results forthcoming)

Overwintering Covers
New overwintering fleece cover in various layers on 20 cultivars, including a sandwich of straw between white poly layers, and one or two layers of fleece (thick felt material) with and without a white poly covering (funding by New England Greenhouse Conference; plant donations courtesy of Creek Hill Nursery, PA), compared with same cultivars under controlled freezing. Performed 2003--04, 2004-05.  Results forthcoming.
Photos: before covering fall 2003 | after covering 2003 | before 2004 | after 2004 | close-up 2004

Media and fertility
Three cultivars (Hemerocallis Stella d'Oro, Geranium 'Max Frei', Dianthus 'Arctic Fire') were potted in 12 combinations of media and fertility to observe effects on growth after one season.  Media include commercial peat-lite, local organic, and German peat-lite products.  Fertility include organic liquid, standard liquid, and new color-coded Osmocote products.
Fertility and media 2003 results | Fertility and media 2004 results

Effects of composts and fertility on perennials 
In summer 2008, five perennials (Ice Dance Carex, Becky Shasta daisy, Brandywine foamflower, Apricot Delight yarrow, and Biokovo geranium) were grown in various combinations of a commercial compost medium (Vermont Organics), with synthetic and organic liquid fertilizers, to monitor any labor savings (watering, fertilizer) and plant growth. (funded by Perennial Plant Association)


In summer 2009, six perennials (Ice Dance, Becky, Bevans geranium, Rhapsody in Blue salvia, Brandywine, and Caramel coralbells ) were grown with three fertilizers (2 rates of a 4-3-2 organic poultry product and Nutricoat) and two media (ProMix BX as a control with a new cow manure based product from Vermont Organics Reclamation also with coffee wastes and perlite 4:1:1 v:v:v) to determine possibility of the latter medium for production.  

 

Beginning in late summer 2010, and continuing into early summer 2011, two revised media from this firm with 11 cultivars was compared against two commercial media, with no practical differences among media.  2011 media report | 2011 media and cultivar photos

Powdery mildew studies (U):
    New cultivars (15) of beebalm were established in 1998 (H) for evaluation for genetic resistance to powdery mildew in a randomized complete block design. Plants were evaluated for drought, weed and cold stress early 2000, then potted for subsequent mildew studies at the UVM greenhouse (U). Due to poor growth in pots, plants were put into field studies in Milton in 2003. Plants will be dug, divided, and potted this year for continued trials in pots.   
    During 2000 and 2001, 5 organic controls were tested on Snow White bee balm (see article below) in containers (U). In 2003 a study with Phlox pan. Mt Fuji was established to look at the effect of salt and milk solutions on mildew, as have proved effective on grapes and vegetable crops.    
    Beginning in 2003, 24 new cultivars of garden phlox will be compared in a randomized complete block design for resistance to powdery mildew in field studies in Milton. (8/03 photo). No results were obtained this first year, due to poor mildew pressure, with the study to be repeated in 2004.
[Slide Show on past studies of powdery mildew on phlox and monarda.]
1998 Scientific article on powdery mildew among bee balm cultivars
1999 Scientific article on organic powdery mildew controls on phlox
2000 Scientific article on organic powdery mildew controls on bee balm
Article on Bee Balm cultivar stress results
Powdery Mildew on Phlox and Monarda leaflet(new 12/01)
Powdery Mildew Controls on Phlox and Monarda leaflet (new 12/01)

New England Aster cultivar rust resistance (U):
About 15 cultivars of Aster novae-angliae were established for evaluation for genetic resistance to rust in a randomized complete block design in the field.  After two years of defoliation due to lacebugs, plants were potted and moved to the UVM greenhouse.  With poor growth in pots, plants of the 12 cultivars were subsequently planted in randomized complete block field studies in Milton in 2003 with data obtained late in the a season (2003 rust article).  Data were not available since due to  minimal rust and subsequent browsing by deer and groundhogs.  

Lilac Evaluation (M):
Okay, they're not herbaceous perennials, but are effective in our climate used in combination with them, and a key shrub in Vermont.  This evaluation over many years of over 230 varieties emphasizes bloom and disease resistance, with many photos and a table of blight resistance observations.

Ornamental grass hardiness (H,M, U)--1999 data:
At 3 sites in the Champlain Valley (USDA zones 4a, 4b and 5b), at least 2 dozen cultivars of ornamental grasses were evaluated over a five year period for winter hardiness, as well as other landscape features. Many are recent introductions to the U.S. from Germany including new ones this year. Results were included with those from an extensive collaborative national effort.


Appreciation is expressed to New England Grows; New England Greenhouse Conference; Vermont Nursery and Landscape Assn.;  New Hampshire Horticulture Endowment; Perennial Plant Association; Greenleaf, Sunny Border, North Creek and Dunvegan nurseries; UVM Extension; VT Agr. Experiment Station. Thanks to Burlington Parks and Recreation for assistance and making possible the Waterfront Park display beds.
    

 Where am I?  Perry's Perennial Pages|   Sustainable Perennials Research